United States Fed Opens Stress Tests to Yearly Public Comment

by admin
United States Fed Opens Stress Tests to Yearly Public Comment

United States regulators at the Federal Reserve Board finalized rules on Sept. 30, 2026 requiring yearly public input on stress test scenarios and averaging stress capital buffers from Jan. 1, 2029.

The Federal Reserve Board on Sept. 30, 2026 adopted two final rules on large-bank stress tests, opening scenarios to yearly comment and averaging capital requirements1.

In short, large U.S. banks will see the hypothetical crisis scenarios and key model changes before each test and can comment on them. Their capital requirements should also swing less from year to year, because the Board will average two years of test results from 20292.

The Board said the two rules together are likely to cut year-over-year volatility in capital requirements by about 50%1. It does not expect them to change total capital requirements across the industry in a material way1.

What does the Fed stress test transparency rule require?

The first rule is titled "Enhanced Transparency and Public Accountability of the Supervisory Stress Test Models and Scenarios"3. It amends Regulations Y, LL and YY, the Board’s rules for bank holding companies, savings and loan holding companies and enhanced prudential standards3.

What the transparency rule requires

Yearly public input on scenarios Invited by the Board every year
Public input on model changes Applies to any material model change
Updated FR Y-14A/Q/M reports Changes to stress test data collection

A stress test is a simulation of how a bank’s capital would hold up in a severe recession. Under the rule, the Board must invite public input every year on the test scenarios and on any material model changes1. The rule also:

  • updates the framework that guides how the hypothetical scenarios are designed1;
  • adopts the models the Board will use for the 2027 stress test1;
  • makes several adjustments to the stress test calendar1;
  • changes the stress test data collection, the FR Y-14A/Q/M reports3.

Until now, the rules only required the Board to tell firms the scenarios by Feb. 15 each year3. The new process adds a public comment step before scenarios and model changes are final.

How will the global market shock change?

The global market shock is a set of sudden hypothetical losses applied to banks with large trading books1. Banks with significant trading activity have recognized these losses in the first quarter of the test period3.

Under the final rule, these banks will face two global market shock components each year1. The Board will use whichever shock produces the larger losses for each firm to calculate its results1. For trading-heavy banks, this means the worse of two scenarios now drives their outcome.

How will buffer averaging work from 2029?

The stress capital buffer is an extra layer of capital each large bank must hold, sized by its losses in the stress test2. It equals the drop in a bank’s core capital ratio under the severe scenario, plus four quarters of planned dividends2. The buffer has a minimum of 2.5% of a firm’s risk-weighted assets, a measure of assets adjusted for risk2.

Stress capital buffer, old and new

QuestionBeforeUnder the final rule
Capital decline usedLatest test onlyAverage of two latest tests
Annual start dateOct. 1Jan. 1
Dividend partUpdated yearlyUpdated yearly, not averaged

The second rule, "Modifications to the Capital Plan Rule and Stress Capital Buffer Requirement," changes how that buffer is set2. For a firm tested in two consecutive years, the Board will average the capital decline from the two most recent tests2. The dividend part is not averaged and will still be updated every year2.

Averaging will begin with buffer requirements effective Jan. 1, 2029, following the 2028 stress test2. The Board said it waits until 2028 so that only models built with public input feed the calculation1.

A firm not tested in two straight years will have its buffer based on its latest test alone2. If a firm has a material change in its risk profile, finances or structure, the Board generally will not average when it recalculates the buffer2.

When will new buffer requirements start each year?

The second rule moves the annual start date of the stress capital buffer from Oct. 1 to Jan. 1 for all firms subject to it2. The Board said the extra quarter gives firms more time to comply2.

To match the new date, the dividend part of the buffer will now cover dividends in quarters five through eight of the test’s planning period2. The rule also drops a policy of phasing in highly material model changes over two years2.

Which banks fall under the Fed stress test rules?

The stress capital buffer rules generally apply to firms with $100 billion or more in total consolidated assets3. These include large bank holding companies, savings and loan holding companies, U.S. holding companies of foreign banks, and nonbank financial companies the Board supervises2.

Firms in the Board’s Category I to III, the largest groups, take the test every year2. Firms in Category IV are generally tested every other year2. That split matters for averaging, which applies only to firms tested in two consecutive years.

What happened to the 2025 proposals?

The Board proposed the averaging rule on April 22, 2025, and received 16 comments on it2. It proposed the transparency changes in October 20253. The Board said both final rules are largely similar to those proposals1.

At the same time, the Board asked for comment on a new model for noninterest income, the fee income each bank is projected to earn under stress1. The aim is to better reflect differences in banks’ business models1. Comments are due 60 days after Federal Register publication1.

When do the stress test rules take effect?

The transparency rule takes effect 30 days after publication in the Federal Register3. The buffer averaging rule takes effect 60 days after publication2. The new net income data in the FR Y-14 reports will be required from the June 30, 2027 report date2.

Days after Federal Register publication until each rule takes effect

Buffer averaging rule 60 days
Transparency rule 30 days

Sources

  1. ↩ Federal Reserve Board – Federal Reserve Board finalizes changes to enhance the transparency and public accountability of its stress test and reduce volatility in its stress test-related capital requirements https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/bcreg20260930a.htm
  2. ↩ Federal Register notice: Modifications to the Capital Plan Rule and Stress Capital Buffer Requirement https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/files/bcreg20260930a2.pdf
  3. ↩ Federal Register notice: Enhanced Transparency and Public Accountability of the Supervisory Stress Test Models and Scenarios; Modifications to the Capital Planning and Stress Capital Buffer Requirement Rule, Enhanced Prudential Standards Rule, and Regulation LL https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/files/bcreg20260930a3.pdf

You may also like