Canada Bans Chargebacks in Investment Fund Sales from Oct. 1, 2028

by admin
Canada Bans Chargebacks in Investment Fund Sales from Oct. 1, 2028

Canada’s securities regulators adopted NI 31-103 amendments banning chargebacks on adviser commissions in publicly offered investment fund sales, effective Oct. 1, 2028.

The Canadian Securities Administrators on Oct. 8, 2026 adopted amendments to securities registration rules that ban chargebacks when dealers sell publicly offered investment funds, with the ban set to start on Oct. 1, 20281.

The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) is the council of the securities regulators of Canada’s provinces and territories2. The amendments change National Instrument 31-103 Registration Requirements, Exemptions and Ongoing Registrant Obligations, the national rulebook for registered dealers and advisers (NI 31-103)1.

In short, dealer firms will no longer be allowed to claw back a sales commission from an adviser because a client sold fund units early. Firms that pay advisers this way have two years to redesign their pay plans, policies and training.

What is a chargeback in fund sales?

Under a chargeback model, a dealing representative is paid an upfront commission when a client buys securities1. If the client redeems all or part of those securities before a fixed schedule ends, the representative must pay back all or part of that commission1. The dealer firm generally sets that schedule, which the CSA calls the Chargeback Period1.

The regulators see a built-in conflict of interest in this pay model. An adviser keeps the full commission only if the client stays invested past the Chargeback Period1. That can push an adviser to talk a client out of selling, even when the client wants or needs the money1.

The CSA also warns that the conflict can surface during routine reviews. When an adviser checks whether a holding still suits a client, the adviser may be tempted to recommend keeping it to avoid a repayment1. The conflict grows as the upfront commission gets larger and the Chargeback Period gets longer1.

"By prohibiting chargebacks in the distribution of investment fund securities, we are removing a compensation structure that can create conflicts between an advisor’s interests and those of their clients," said Stan Magidson, CSA Chair and Chair and CEO of the Alberta Securities Commission, in the CSA news release2.

Which Canadian dealers and funds are covered?

The ban applies to all registrants involved in selling securities of investment funds that are reporting issuers1. A reporting issuer is a fund that has offered its securities to the public and files ongoing reports with regulators. The CSA news release describes this as publicly offered investment fund distribution2.

The CSA says current use of chargebacks is limited1. It chose to act now, before the practice becomes entrenched and widespread1. The regulators compare the problem to the deferred sales charge, a fee investors paid for selling early, which is already banned1. The difference is that a chargeback is a payment between the adviser and the firm, not a charge on the investor1.

The notice names one group most affected: scholarship plan dealers, firms that sell education savings plans1. Two such dealers would need to rework their pay practices and compliance systems to comply1. For some of them, chargebacks have been part of pay arrangements for more than a decade1.

The release lists 13 jurisdictions for the final amendments: Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia, Nunavut, Ontario, Prince Edward Island, Québec, Saskatchewan and Yukon2. The BC Securities Commission did not take part in the release because of publication limits tied to the British Columbia provincial election2.

Which commission recoveries fall outside the CSA ban?

An industry group asked the regulators to say exactly which commission recoveries are banned1. The CSA answered with two scenarios that sit outside the ban, though neither is free of scrutiny.

Outside the chargeback ban

Cancelled automatic purchase plans Recovery not triggered by a redemption
Transfers to another institution Outside the ban unless a redemption comes first
Purchases before the effective date Covered by the legacy provision

The first covers pre-authorized contributions, regular automatic purchases, and auto-switches1. Some firms pay advisers upfront on the expected value of such a plan. If the client cancels partway, for example after 6 months of a 12-month plan, the firm may recover part of the commission1. That recovery is not triggered by a redemption, so the ban does not cover it1.

The CSA still calls this an inherent conflict that is almost always material1. Registrants must deal with it in the client’s best interest, which may mean avoiding such pay structures altogether1.

The second scenario covers recoveries tied to transfers of an account to another financial institution1. These are also outside the ban when no redemption triggers them1. However, the ban does apply if a redemption happens before the transfer1.

Why did the deadline move to October 2028?

The CSA first published the proposal for comment on June 26, 20251. At that stage the ban would have taken effect six months after final publication1. The regulators received 22 comment letters1.

Time to comply with the chargeback ban, months

6 months June 2025 proposal
24 months Final amendments

Most commenters backed the ban1. Some industry groups objected, saying existing conflict-of-interest rules already cover the practice1. One commenter pointed to insurance regulators, who propose to keep allowing chargebacks on segregated funds under guidance1. The CSA said securities and insurance firms operate under different rules but that it will keep working toward a common approach1.

Several commenters said firms would need more time to redesign pay models, and some dealers asked for at least two years1. The CSA agreed and set a 24-month implementation period1. It judged this a non-material change, so it will not republish the rules for more comment1.

What must firms change before Oct. 1, 2028?

The CSA expects registered firms to review and amend their compensation practices and compliance systems1. The main tasks it lists are:

  • updating policies, procedures and controls to enforce the ban1
  • changing how advisers are paid on fund sales1
  • training registered representatives on the new rules1

What dealer firms must do

RequirementDetails
Compliance systemsUpdate policies, procedures and controls to enforce the ban
Adviser payChange how advisers are paid on fund sales
TrainingTrain registered representatives on the new rules
Start dateOct. 1, 2028, subject to ministerial approvals

The work should match the scale of each firm’s operations1.

A legacy provision limits the reach of the ban. It does not apply when a client redeems fund securities bought before the effective date1. Existing chargeback arrangements on older purchases can therefore run their course.

The Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO), the national self-regulatory body for investment dealers, helped develop the amendments1. CIRO expects to change its member rules, policies and guidance so they match the amendments in all material respects1.

Summary of the NI 31-103 chargeback ban

The table sets out the core facts of the amendments.

Key DimensionDetails
Regulating Authority & JurisdictionCanadian Securities Administrators; final amendments listed for 13 provinces and territories2
InstrumentAmendments to National Instrument 31-103 Registration Requirements, Exemptions and Ongoing Registrant Obligations1
Scope & Who Must ComplyAll registrants involved in selling securities of investment funds that are reporting issuers1
Core Mandate / Key ChangeBan on clawing back an adviser’s upfront commission when a client redeems before a fixed schedule ends1
ExemptionsRedemptions of securities bought before the effective date; recoveries on cancelled pre-authorized contributions or transfers not triggered by a redemption1
Key Dates & Implementation MilestonesProposed June 26, 2025; adopted Oct. 8, 2026; in force Oct. 1, 2028, subject to ministerial approvals1
Consultation22 comment letters; implementation period extended from six months to 24 months1
Enforcement ActionCIRO expects to align its member rules, policies and guidance with the amendments1

Some jurisdictions still need ministerial approval1. Once those approvals are obtained, the ban takes effect on Oct. 1, 20281.

Sources

  1. ↩ 6304440-CSA-Notice-Amendments-to-NI-31-103.pdf https://www.asc.ca/-/media/ASC-Documents-part-1/Regulatory-Instruments/2026/10/6304440-CSA-Notice-Amendments-to-NI-31-103.pdf
  2. ↩ Canadian securities regulators publish final amendments prohibiting chargebacks in investment fund distribution – Canadian Securities Administrators https://www.securities-administrators.ca/news/canadian-securities-regulators-publish-final-amendments-prohibiting-chargebacks-in-investment-fund-distribution/

You may also like