EU Adopts New Rules on ESG Factors in Credit Rating Methods

by admin
EU Adopts New Rules on ESG Factors in Credit Rating Methods

The European Commission adopted two rules on how credit rating agencies explain, review and check methods, including ESG factors.

The European Commission has adopted two new rules on how credit rating agencies build, explain and check their rating methods. The rules aim to make the role of environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in credit ratings easier for investors to see.

The Commission adopted both acts on 9 November 2026, under the EU’s Credit Rating Agencies Regulation (CRA Regulation), Regulation (EC) No 1060/20091. Neither act is in force until it is published in the Official Journal, the EU’s official record of laws1. The European Parliament now has an initial period of 3 months to examine the first act2.

At a glanceDetails
What was publishedTwo Commission delegated regulations, adopted but not yet in force
Published on9 November 2026
Who must complyCredit rating agencies covered by the CRA Regulation
Effective dateNot yet set: the acts apply only after publication in the Official Journal
Next milestoneReview by the European Parliament’s economic affairs committee

What did the Commission adopt?

The Commission’s page on the CRA Regulation lists two delegated regulations adopted on 9 November 20261. A delegated regulation is a rule the Commission writes under powers given to it by an existing EU law. The CRA Regulation gives the Commission those powers1.

ActWhat it covers
Act amending Annex I of the CRA RegulationTransparency, review and validation of rating methods1
Act amending Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012Transparency and use of ESG factors in rating methods1

Annex I of the CRA Regulation sets out what agencies must disclose about their ratings and methods3. Delegated Regulation 447/2012 explains how an agency shows that its rating method is rigorous, systematic, continuous and checked3.

Why ESG factors in credit ratings matter

A credit rating is an agency’s opinion of how likely a borrower is to repay its debts. ESG factors include climate risks, social issues and how a company is governed. The question is how far such factors shape a rating, and whether investors can see it.

The work began with a request from the Commission in June 20233. It asked the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU’s markets supervisor, for advice. The aim was better incorporation of ESG factors in rating methods and more disclosure to the public3.

ESMA sent its final advice in a report dated 18 December 20243. That report said the goal was better tracing of ESG factors in rating methods. It also sought clearer disclosure of how relevant ESG factors are to each rating action3.

How ESMA shaped the proposals

ESMA consulted the public from 2 April 2024 until 21 June 20243. It received 19 responses, three of them confidential3. Nine came from credit rating agencies and 10 from industry groups, funds, banks, insurers and pension funds3.

Consultation by the numbersDetails
Consultation opened2 April 20243
Consultation closed21 June 20243
Total responses19, including 3 confidential3
From rating agencies93
From other groups103

Most respondents backed more openness about ESG factors in rating methods3. Many warned against rules that were too rigid. They objected to labelling each rating factor as environmental, social or governance3.

ESMA changed its advice in response. Its revised wording no longer required agencies to identify and sort factors that way3. ESMA also described a rating method as the framework used to set a rating, including criteria, models and key assumptions3.

The Commission’s page lists the two acts by title only. It does not say which parts of ESMA’s advice the final acts keep.

What changes for credit rating agencies

The first act deals with review and validation of methods. Validation means testing whether a rating method works as intended. ESMA’s advice found general support for agencies disclosing how they validate their methods3.

Respondents also supported making the review function responsible for validation3. The review function is the team inside an agency that checks its rating methods. The second act focuses on how ESG factors are built into methods and explained to the public1.

Timeline and next steps

The Parliament’s legislative tracker shows that the first act was published as a Commission document on 9 November 20262. Its referral to the Parliament’s Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee (ECON) was announced on 11 November 20262. The file is now awaiting a committee decision2.

Key dateWhat happens
June 2023Commission asks ESMA for advice3
18 December 2024ESMA final advice report3
9 November 2026Commission adopts both acts1
11 November 2026Referral to ECON announced in Parliament2
NextPublication in the Official Journal, then entry into force1

The examination period on the tracker starts at 3 months2. The Commission’s page says each act is not in force until Official Journal publication1.

Key terms in plain words

TermMeaning
Credit rating agencyA firm that grades how likely a borrower is to repay debt
ESG factorsEnvironmental, social and governance issues, such as climate risk or company management
Delegated regulationA detailed rule the Commission writes under powers from an existing EU law
ValidationTesting whether a rating method works as intended
Official JournalThe EU’s official publication where new laws appear
ESMAThe European Securities and Markets Authority, which supervises EU rating agencies

The next official step is the end of the European Parliament’s initial 3-month examination of the first act, which began on 9 November 20262.

Sources

  1. ↩ Credit Rating Agencies Regulation – Finance – European Commission https://finance.ec.europa.eu/regulation-and-supervision/financial-services-legislation/implementing-and-delegated-acts/credit-rating-agencies-regulation_en
  2. ↩ Procedure File: 2026/2967(DEA) | Legislative Observatory | European Parliament https://oeil.secure.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/en/procedure-file?reference=2026/2967(DEA)
  3. ↩ ESMA84-2037069784-2196_Final_Report_Amendment_to_Delegated_Regulation_447-2012_and_Annex_I_of_CRA_Regulation.pdf https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2024-12/ESMA84-2037069784-2196_Final_Report_Amendment_to_Delegated_Regulation_447-2012_and_Annex_I_of_CRA_Regulation.pdf

You may also like